
Home Depot’s next CEO isn’t arriving with a stranger’s map of the business. Richard McPhail takes over on November 23, with Ted Decker staying as chair and two other longtime executives moving into bigger roles. For shareholders, this looks more like a handoff of an existing strategy than a promise to start over. The interesting question is how that team balances sales growth, profit dollars and margins.
The company announced the appointments on November 17, alongside quarterly results. McPhail becomes CEO and a director, Ann-Marie Campbell becomes president and chief operating officer, and Jordan Broggi becomes executive vice president and chief financial officer. All three appointments take effect November 23.
A handoff, not a clean break
There’s more going on here than a new name on the office door. Campbell adds supply chain, customer-experience operations and online to her responsibilities. Broggi moves into the CFO seat after leading interconnected retail, with earlier finance roles on his résumé. McPhail has been CFO since 2019.
That combination makes me curious about coordination: how store operations, digital shopping and spending decisions fit together. An impressive résumé can explain why someone was picked. It can’t tell us how smoothly the next difficult decision will go.
The leadership filing adds an important distinction. The board approved the changes November 13. The interim Office of the CEO, overseen by Campbell and McPhail during Decker’s leave, ends November 23. Decker remains a compensated chair; he isn’t leaving the company.
So this isn’t simply an outsider replacing an absent leadership team. Campbell and McPhail have already shared oversight of the interim CEO office. I’d judge the transition by what changes in execution, rather than treating the appointment itself as evidence that execution has improved.
The sales progress comes with a margin question
Home Depot’s third-quarter release, covering the period ended November 1, reported $43.4 billion in sales, up 4.9% year over year. Comparable sales rose 2.2%. GAAP diluted earnings per share increased to $3.72 from $3.62.
But GAAP operating margin slipped to 12.6% from 12.9%. Adjusted operating margin also declined, to 13.0% from 13.3%. The adjusted measure excludes acquired-intangible amortization; it isn’t a replacement for the GAAP result. GAAP operating income nevertheless grew 2.4%, to $5.479 billion from $5.353 billion.
That’s the wrinkle I’d keep on the page beside the leadership announcement. More sales and a smaller operating-profit share of each sales dollar can coexist. It gives the incoming team something specific to demonstrate: how much operating profit growth accompanies the additional revenue. A lower percentage margin doesn’t automatically mean fewer profit dollars or a worse investment.
On the earnings call, management described a softer-than-expected housing backdrop and roofing pressure within SRS. Management explained that lower-margin product and acquisition mix can add sales and earnings while pulling down the percentage margin. Those qualifications matter when assessing a strategy aimed at professional customers. “Pro” isn’t one perfectly synchronized customer with one shopping list.
The updated outlook isn’t a blanket upgrade
Comparing the new forecast with August’s guidance is more useful than assigning the whole announcement a cheerful or gloomy label. Expected fiscal-2026 sales growth is now approximately 4.5%, the top of the earlier 2.5%–4.5% range. Expected GAAP operating margin is approximately 12.4%, the bottom of the earlier 12.4%–12.6% range.
Those are management forecasts, not finished-year results. The narrowing gives investors a more specific set of expectations, but the direction differs by measure. Calling everything a raise would erase the very tension worth watching.
Our guide to reading an earnings report walks through margins and guidance together. Here, I’d keep the original ranges and the new estimates side by side, rather than letting the leadership news swallow the financial update.
What would make continuity convincing?
McPhail backed the existing strategy on the call. I want to see whether that continuity produces clearer evidence of progress across the businesses, including the parts facing pressure. A stronger quarter from one operation shouldn’t automatically become a verdict on every other operation.
Campbell’s expanded remit also makes the connection between stores, delivery and online service worth following. Better coordination would be useful; declaring it achieved before the new structure takes effect would be getting rather ahead of the moving boxes.
The handoff gives investors a named team and a clear start date. The next results will help answer the harder question: how the same strategic direction, under this leadership arrangement, balances growth and profitability.
For general education. This analysis is not personalized investment advice.

